Islam 201 - The Future of this blog, the future of this Muslim
April 20, 2008 | 13 Rabbi al-Thanni 1429

Casco del Almirante Turco Vencido en Lepanto “How can we sleep when are beds are burnin’?” It’s amazing the hikmah one can find in an old 80’s pop song. Indeed, the time has come. Not to worry, this isn’t a signing off memo for the author of this blog. Instead, it’s a manifesto or perhaps a mirror in which to examine myself within the greater context of that which I live. For those of you who have been consistent readers over the last several years, that would indeed seem to be much of the underlying point of this blog. The proverbial steam has reached 45 degrees.

A quick scan of the Muslim blogosphere, particularly the Blackamerican blogs, renders a mixture of angst, indignation, soul searching and a mixed bag of other emotions. To put it simply, [Black]American Muslims are having an existential crisis. From lack of authority to lack of learning, Modernity circles the camp, constantly threatening, constantly throwing confusion into the mix. This blog has tried to be a voice of reason, a voice of the alternative amidst this crisis. But after even a periphery scan amongst fellow bloggers it would seem we’ve gathered enough data to come to the conclusion that what has been put forth is not bearing fruit for Muslims today. So the question that begs an answer is what are we, as [Black]American Muslims going to do about this deficit? I for one say it’s time for a little less pixelation and a bit more connectivity of the face-to-face variety. In other words, as Hall & Oates put it, “One on one, I want to play that game to night…”

For me, my part was to get directly involved in the game. Over the past several months, I have come into contact with a variety of Muslims who have been earnestly seeking out some type of guidance. Everything from new Muslims who have been left in a state of dysfunction after the big hoorah of their shahadah to Muslims who’ve “fallen off the wagon” but are searching out some rehabilitation. It immediately occurred to me that blogging was going to do these people no good. And while one of them even recognized me from my blog, it wasn’t more Internet fatwahs that the individual was after. Rather, a living, breathing mentorship that could provide simple yet concrete answers to his/her questions. This has resoundingly been the case with the rest of the Muslims I have been conducting a class for - a class on Muslim development and spiritual growth. I am not stating this as a means to garner attention to myself [riya’] but rather to state that this is simply what we need more of. I will provide a couple of case points to back up my assertion.

It would be doubly redundant to state that new Muslims are left to the sharks when it comes to Muslim growth. Most masajid that I have encountered have poorly functional classes for new shahadahs if they even have one at all. One Muslim, after having taken his shahadah some three to four years ago, is barely able to recite two suwrahs [al-Fatihah and al-Ikhlas] for his obligatory prayers. The criticism [and most certainly not of the individual] isn’t that s/he hasn’t taken the time to memorize more suwrahs but that s/he was never give the means to do so in the first place. This points to an even greater disparity as is the case with many of the Muslims I have encountered through this class, is that they are so afraid to approach the Qur’an due to their lack of Arabic or other skills, that they simply don’t approach it at all.

The second profound issue is that most of them are lacking in basic, fundamental creedal knowledge of their religion. Many have now been filled with a laundry list of ideas and concepts from a salad bar Muslim education that many harbor doubts about their faith. Simple things that they encounter like popular science’s attack on religion to the susceptibility of erroneous information leave them every way but up when it comes to what they really believe. It is a sad, woefully sad testimony of our condition when we turn out people to the streets armed with little more than a scant notion of their religion and leave them to be devoured by the waswasat that wonder every street corner, that emanate from every television and media outlet. But not to despair. Like a plant that has been parched even a little water can resucitate the individual. And in addition, I have found the experience thus far to be exciting, rewarding and in sha’ Allah, showing signs of success in that if given a balanced, systematized way of learning their religion, with roots connecting them to the Tradition of Islam, but an articulation of the religion that opens up psychological spaces for them, they are able to banish major doubts and begin work on other matters of the soul.

As I stated, and I do heartedly so again, this is not to bring more attention to myself nor is this a call to gather more students. In fact, I am at my limit in terms of time and capacity at this point. Indeed, I will be the first to admit that this is not an ideal situation as I am only one individual and can only teach a few other individuals - the numbers of those who are in need, those who are seeking, is far larger than one person to handle alone. So it is my hope, that a process and a system can be realized and implemented that will educate new Muslims about their religion, giving them the tools, pre-shahadah, to function as Muslims in this society and God willing, even contribute something to it. It should also be a system that provides education and spiritual growth for Muslims that, upon entering Islam, their spiritual growth arrested. Classes in hadith methodology and usual al-fiqh are not sufficient by themselves and may not even be appropriate for individuals who have not grasped the basic creedal fundamentals.

So in the end, while this is not farewell post, it is a call to lay down the pen of criticizing for a bit. I have come to the conclusion that we all understand there’s issues now. Perhaps it’s time to get our hands dirty a bit, reach out and see what we can do to get things going. Negativity breeds more of its own ilk than can a barrow full of rabbits.“A fact’s a fact. It belongs to them. Let’s give it back.”

Posted in Islam, Musings | Tags: , , , , ,

10 Responses to “Islam 201 - The Future of this blog, the future of this Muslim”

  1. Me in the Mirror Says:

    […] Marc writes, on the BAM issue: A quick scan of the Muslim blogosphere, particularly the Blackamerican blogs, renders a mixture of angst, indignation, soul searching and a mixed bag of other emotions. To put it simply, [Black]American Muslims are having an existential crisis. From lack of authority to lack of learning, Modernity circles the camp, constantly threatening, constantly throwing confusion into the mix. […]

  2. Charles Says:

    Salaam brother,

    We have also set the wheels in motion for more small tutorial and discussion classes here in Columbus and Northeast Ohio. It’s been a little difficult finding those who need help but we aer getting more inquiries now.

  3. Eva Says:

    Salam! I would be honored to have you as a member. Hope you don’t mind the plug! If you do, feel free to delete. Wish you’d join! Thanks!
    ISLAMIC BLOG DIRECTORY

  4. Margari Aziza Says:

    Masha’Allah. I’m glad the issues have been pointed out and that there is open debate. But some of the feuds have gotten out of hand. Some people live for controversy, others are striving for leadership positions. Others step in as intermediaries on a need be basis. I would like to think I was one of those. But making those constant interventions and correctives can be overwhelming. I’m not saying I’m a totally reasonable voice, but I just tried to be honest about the struggle. Personally, I feel like they have taken me away from the real work I should be doing. But I am grateful for the lessons I’ve learned. I hope you share the curriculum with other communities. As for the blogosphere, we still need a voice of reason. We still need to hear little words of wisdom, some gems every now and then. So whenever you are inspired, drop a line here and there.

  5. Sister Seeking Says:

    Ma’sha’Allah, la hawla wa la quta ila bilah…

    You are right brother Marc…

    Some sisters and I are going to be starting a spiritual support group in my home. By the way everybody, we settled and closed last Thursday.

    You are right brother, seek knowledge, reflect and TAKE ACTION.

    Even though you didn’t like me, I was reading your blog.

    Take care of your self, and I’m kind of sad to see you all going but I understand.

    I just wanted to say that all you BAM really made me proud, and gave me HOPE. I didn’t realize that people like you all even existed in the community.

    May Allah forgive us for our shortcomings, and guide us all.- Ameen
    Sister Seeking

  6. Sister Seeking Says:

    Sister Azizah

    Keep in touch sister, and let me know if you ever publish your research and your other work.

    SS

  7. Marc Says:

    Even though you didn’t like me, I was reading your blog.

    Sister - I never said I didn’t like you. Just might have disagreed with a few things you said but to just out and not like you would be kind of harsh. al-Hamdulillah, I’m glad you enjoyed what you’ve seen or read. May Allah give you success with your class.

  8. Saifuddin Says:

    Bismillahar Rahmanir Rahim

    as-salaamu ‘alaikum. Marc, this post, your blog and your presence at the event shows evidence of your sincerity. You looked good, mashaAllah. It was a pleasure meeting you at Columbia. I would like to meet again, inshaAllah, the next time you are in NYC. Then perhaps we can talk about things further.

    -Saifuddin

  9. HijabMan Says:

    “Many have now been filled with a laundry list of ideas and concepts from a salad bar Muslim education that many harbor doubts about their faith”

    Very well put. It truly is a salad bar. And they all pick different veggies, but never see the whole salad. :-P

  10. NM Says:

    As Salamu Alaykum

    I think that this is an awesome post and timely. It’s funny, I was actually scanning your page to find a post to offer thanks for the times that you have given me advice via emails, even though you don’t know me in the flesh. I’ve been out of it for a minute and have taken a “break” for the last few months as I was bewildered upon leaving Cali. All the same, I feel better prepared to get back on the wagon and that’s in part due very much to bloggers like you. So rock out your in-person thing, but don’t discredit what you’ve meant to others via a mac and dsl! I’m indeed grateful to have known you virtually. One question: I had a very difficult time in California, but school is cheap there, Zaytuna’s there and I know the pitfalls of the community there (it’s the only umma I know and I love ‘em even when it hurts). Considering that I am Maliki and the East somewhat shuns madhabs, is there a hub of knowledge that you think I should consider prior to roadtripping back to Cali?

    Warmest

Leave a Reply

Archives

Meta

  • Prayer Times

    Philadelphia
    Prayer Time
    Fajr 4:24 AM
    Sunrise 5:52 AM
    Dhuhur 1:08 AM
    Asr 5:03 PM
    Maghrib 8:22 PM
    Isha 9:52 PM
  • Links